BROOKLYN NINE-NINE: Tuesday 8:30PM on FOX
Previously… on BROOKLYN NINE-NINE: Fun and games in a Brooklyn police precinct. Jake Peralta (Andy Samberg) is the ace detective who solves crimes but is happily slovenly about everything else in his life. Now he has to deal with a new boss, Captain Ray Holt (Andre Braugher), who’s the epitome of by-the-book. The precinct house also features Amy Santiago (Melissa Fumero), Jake’s main competitor on the squad; dim bulb Boyle (Joe Lo Truglio); Rosa Diaz (Stephanie Beatriz), the tough detective Boyle not-so-secretly adores; married Sergeant Terry Jeffords (Terry Crews); and civilian administrator Gina (Chelsea Peretti).
Episode 2: So far, Brooklyn Nine-Nine is a lot more interested in gags than its characters, a bit of a surprise from creators Michael Schur and Dan Goor, who both hail from Parks & Recreation. The second episode, written by Consulting Producer Norm Hiscock and directed by Craig Zisk, has Peralta, under pressure from Captain Holt to start following the rules and do his paperwork properly, finding himself arresting a tagger who draws penises on squad cars, which turns out to be a clue to the fact that he’s a Deputy Commissioner’s son. Peralta has to decide whether to let the kid slide or do the right thing, and–what a shock–he finally places the little stinker under arrest, earning a tinge of respect from Holt. Meanwhile, the B story centers on Boyle, who’s told by a medium friend of Gina’s that the woman he loves will never love him back, making him miserable once he decides she does have the gift (even though she said drugs would be found somewhere blue and yellow, Gina convinces him that green counts because it mixes the two colors), until Diaz tells him we all make our own destinies.
There were a few laughs here, especially when Peralta showed off his nifty perfectly compiled report in the tagger case (he’d spent an hour on the fonts, and it even included an “About the Author” section with a photo on the back cover), and the chemistry between Samberg and Braugher is fun. There’s not much of an ensemble feel to the show, though, which is clearly the two of them and then everybody else–there’s barely a hair of difference between tough detective Santiago and tough detective Diaz. Any romantic sparks between Peralta and Santiago are gone for now, which leaves no storytelling about the characters interacting, unless you count Boyle’s crush on Diaz.
Brooklyn Nine-Nine is a pleasant enough show, and it certainly outclasses its lead-in Dads by a mile, but it doesn’t feel distinctive. For the most part, Samberg is still playing Peralta like a sketch comic (and gags like him camping out in the squad room so he won’t be late in the morning support that approach), and Braugher is the only one who seems grounded in any kind of reality. It famously took Parks & Recreation its first season to find its voice, of course, and hopes are high that Brooklyn will too. It started well in the ratings with a 2.6 (better than last night’s debut of Mom on CBS, although last week it faced only pre-season competition), and if those numbers hold up, it should have time to decide what kind of show it’s going to be.
ORIGINAL VERDICT: Potential DVR Alert
PILOT + 1: A Work In Progress
Related Posts
-
THE SKED SEASON FINALE REVIEWS
With the 2011-12 broadcast season now concluded, here’s a list of all our Season Finale reviews at The Sked: 2 BROKE GIRLS 30 ROCK 90210 AWAKE BONES COMMUNITY More after the break– CSI DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES DON’T TRUST THE B___ IN APT 23 FRINGE GLEE THE GOOD WIFE GOSSIP GIRL GREY’S…
-
THE SKED Season Finale Review: “Brooklyn Nine-Nine”
BROOKLYN NINE-NINE kicked off the beginning of the end of the 2013-14 network television season tonight, the first full-season series to reach its finale, so it’s time to start making some summarizing judgments about the year in television. Brooklyn was the best of the fall’s comedy pilots, and unlike…
-
THE SKED 2013 UPFRONTS: FOX Trailer – “Brooklyn Nine-Nine”
One of FOX’s big moves for the fall is revamping its Tuesday 8-9PM comedies, shifting sharply in tone from last falls soft duo of Raising Hope and Ben & Kate to a more guy-oriented tone. Seth MacFarlane’s Dads has the responsibility for kicking off the night, and then the…
-
THE SKED Pilot + 1 Review: “Enlisted”
ENLISTED: Friday 9:30PM on FOX Previously… on ENLISTED: The brothers Hill–demoted hero soldier Pete (Geoff Stults), cynical Derrick (Chris Lowell) and earnest, dumb Randy (Parker Young)–all serve on a Florida Army base, where Pete is Sergeant of his brothers’ platoon. Their commanding officer is one-legged Sergeant Major Wallace (Keith…
-
THE SKED SEASON FINALE REVIEW: “Bones”
There was no way BONES could top its season finale from last year, when the show finally addressed its eternal Will They Or Won’t They? about Dr. Temperance Brennan (Emily Deschanel) and FBI Agent Seeley Booth (David Boreanaz) by cleverly disclosing that they already had, and in fact that…